Archive - Aluminium Camper Forum

Ask the Factory => Ask the factory => Topic started by: spot1 on February 07, 2016, 03:42:57 PM

Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: spot1 on February 07, 2016, 03:42:57 PM
Welcome to the Forum! Did not see the answer to your first question on the LL CL 21BHS product page about current ball size.

On your second question:

We use the following with our Class IV 2" square vehicle hitch:

Purchased our Ultra Tow forged towing ball mount hitch & Ultra Tow ball from Northern Tool. You can purchase a 2" or 2 5/16" balls with 1 1/4" diameter shank from Northern Tool.

The 2" ball we use  with 1 1/4" diameter shank, item # 32787, is rated for 7,500 pound capacity. Northern Tool also has 2 5/16" balls with
1 1/4 diameter shank, item# 32792, rated @ 10,000 pound capacity.

http://www.northerntool.com/shop/tools/category_trailers-towing+hitch-balls

We use Ultra Tow forged towing ball mount hitch, item # 32710, set up for 1 1/4" diameter shank balls, and rated at 17,000 pound capacity.

http://www.northerntool.com/shop/tools/category_trailers-towing+ball-mount-hitches+single-ball-mount

Hope this helps!
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: blairh on February 16, 2016, 12:19:52 PM
[quote source="/post/18484/thread" author="@swilky" timestamp="1454870635"]FACTORY:

I have seen different answers here. What is the current coupler size being installed on the 21BHS?
The new specs show it as 5500lbs GVWR now.
That exceeds max 5000 lbs for 2 inch right?
[/quote]Hi Swilky, the coupler size being installed on the 14s, 16s, and 21s floorplans going forward is 2 5/16". The 2" coupler is no longer being installed
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: charliem on February 16, 2016, 12:53:19 PM
[quote source="/post/18740/thread" timestamp="1455639592" author="@blairh"]Hi Swilky, the coupler size being installed on the 14s, 16s, and 21s floorplans going forward is 2 5/16". The 2" coupler is no longer being installed
[/quote][font size="3"]That's great and welcome news. Are they also installing the side bolts? Tell me yes and I'll go away and sleep  8-) .[/font]
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: gbpack on February 16, 2016, 08:04:55 PM
No on the side bolts. Our new 21BHS didn't have them, so we had our dealer add them. Only took them a few minutes.
I would highly recommend doing it (as do many others on this forum).
GB
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: djsamuel on February 16, 2016, 09:29:34 PM
I would like to know the reason for the switch.  As an owner of a 2013 21BHS with a 2" hitch, it would be nice to know if there was a design issue.  I've towed it almost 8,000 miles so far with no issues; but if there is a potential problem I'd like to know.
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: leslie on February 17, 2016, 08:32:07 AM
I have a 2015 21-BHS with side bolts that I assume the dealer added, since it seems the factory doesn't. We took a trip each month last year, after my husband retired in April. We are now wandering around Central Florida for the winter, and we have had no problems with our coupler. Every time we hitch up, I am checking.
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: gbpack on February 17, 2016, 11:08:11 AM
Quote from: @djsamuel" source="/post/18762/thread" timestamp="1455672574I would like to know the reason for the switch.  As an owner of a 2013 21BHS with a 2" hitch, it would be nice to know if there was a design issue.  I've towed it almost 8,000 miles so far with no issues; but if there is a potential problem I'd like to know.



DJ - per the other threads that have appeared on this forum over the past year or so, it seems as though LL decided to go with the larger coupler on the larger trailers because some of the 2" couplers were bending during use. But LL is still not putting side bolts in the coupler, so that is something that many of us are having done (even if we have the larger coupler). Check out the other threads for detailed info regarding this and pictures of where to put the side bolts.
Gregg
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: djsamuel on February 17, 2016, 11:35:06 AM
[quote source="/post/18776/thread" timestamp="1455721691" author="@gbpack"][quote timestamp="1455672574" source="/post/18762/thread" author="@djsamuel"]I would like to know the reason for the switch.  As an owner of a 2013 21BHS with a 2" hitch, it would be nice to know if there was a design issue.  I've towed it almost 8,000 miles so far with no issues; but if there is a potential problem I'd like to know.[/quote]
DJ - per the other threads that have appeared on this forum over the past year or so, it seems as though LL decided to go with the larger coupler on the larger trailers because some of the 2" couplers were bending during use. But LL is still not putting side bolts in the coupler, so that is something that many of us are having done (even if we have the larger coupler). Check out the other threads for detailed info regarding this and pictures of where to put the side bolts.
Gregg[/quote]The threads regarding bent couplers were always pointing to the weight distribution system being used.  I've used the Andersen WDH with the 2" coupler and no side bolts and have had no bending at all, even thought I've taken the trailer from Florida to places as far away as Arizona and Utah.  However, Livinlite has always recommended against a WDH.  I'm wondering what drove LivinLite to make this change.  Was it to allow for all forms of WDH use, or did they discover another issue that may be lurking for those of us using the 2" hitch?
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: ammobob on February 17, 2016, 08:20:50 PM
One would hope it's just a case of them reading this forum and the issues others have posted. You would think that they would put out something in the form of a technical bulletin if there were true safety issues unknown to us. I have 4000 miles on my trailer with a 2" coupler, side bolts and an Andersom WDS and have seen no signs of bending.
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: montedtrotter1 on February 18, 2016, 08:24:37 AM
I agree with Ammobob, I think LL sees some of the various issues owners post and if they can change them for minimal or no cost why not. They see that owners are using WDH's even when LL says they are not needed. I would not even think about taking my 21BHS on a trip without the WDH! I got the 2 5/16 ball as a result of this forum. The dealer put it on for me including the side bolts, no extra charge. Did I prevent a future problem who knows, but I do not even think about that issue now when I hook up.
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: pinstriper on February 23, 2016, 08:57:12 PM
Quote from: @swilky" source="/post/18934/thread" timestamp="1456264239Answer from factory for newest 21BHS coupler:

2-5/16 14000# Ram CA-5400-Z

Not sure if they are actually welding them now.


Specs:

    Ball size: 2-5/16"
    Jack hole diameter: 2-1/4"
    Overall dimensions: 12-7/8" long x 10-7/8" wide
    Pin hole diameter: 5/16"
        Minimum span needed for pin or pin lock: 7/8"
    Weight capacity: 14,000 lbs



CA-5400-Z Ram A-Frame Trailer Coupler - Thumb Latch - 2-5/16" Ball - Zinc - 14,000 lbs

[a href="https://www.etrailer.com/tv-Demo-etrailer-A-Frame-Trailer-Coupler-CA-5400-Z.aspx"]https://www.etrailer.com/tv-Demo-etrailer-A-Frame-Trailer-Coupler-CA-5400-Z.aspx[/a]



You can't weld steel to aluminum.

Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: blairh on February 24, 2016, 10:57:13 AM
Sorry I haven't been on much lately, busy with many RV and Outdoor shows lately.

I've attached some images showing the 2 5/16" couplers and the bolt patterns associated for the (1) Camplite 14DBS, (2) Quicksilver Tents and (3) Quickilsver VRV 7x20. All those photos came from recently arrived 2016 trailers. I have a 2016 Camplite 21RBS here and the coupler is the exact same as the 14DBS. The couplers aren't welded (of course aluminum cannot be welded to steel), however only the toy haulers have the side bolts through the coupler. If their is concern of the couplers on the Camplite, side bolts can easily be added to match the toy haulers.

Hope this helps clarify.
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: charliem on February 24, 2016, 11:14:47 AM
[font size="3"]Blairh,

Thanks for the pictures. They bring two points to mind: a) why LL Thor doesn't put side bolts on the 21s to fix a known problem and, b) why the bolts on the TH are not further forward to maximize the mechanical advantage? Regardless, the heavier coupler is a good change.

[/font]
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: billmoore on February 24, 2016, 01:26:27 PM
[quote source="/post/18947/thread" timestamp="1456326887" author="@charliem"][font size="3"]Blairh,

Thanks for the pictures. They bring two points to mind: a) why LL Thor doesn't put side bolts on the 21s to fix a known problem and, b) why the bolts on the TH are not further forward to maximize the mechanical advantage? Regardless, the heavier coupler is a good change.

[/font][/quote]I don't think the bolts can go any farther forward, there isn't room. The two frame members come together just in front of where the bolt is located.
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: charliem on February 24, 2016, 06:16:29 PM
[quote source="/post/18948/thread" timestamp="1456334787" author="@billmoore"]I don't think the bolts can go any farther forward, there isn't room. The two frame members come together just in front of where the bolt is located.[/quote][font size="3"]I put the nuts inside the rectangular tubes at the front. As long as the tubes are not welded shut there is access. On my 21RBS there is no access behind the front vertical bolts so I had to put the side bolts up front. Better from a mechanical angle perspective and better because it does not compress and collapse the tubing. Blairh's third picture shows the frame tube extending considerably forward of the side bolt. But whatever works...............

[attachment id="1213" thumbnail="1"]
[/font]
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: billmoore on February 25, 2016, 12:38:29 AM
I actually can't tell if the nuts are inside the tube or the bolt goes all the way through. The Toyhauler frame member has a center support inside the tube that you can see here in this picture:



Because of the center piece, you can't see in to where the bolt is, and to see the back side I would have to remove the tongue jack. If it does go all the way through, I'm not too worried about collapsing the tube since there is that center support to prevent collapsing.

In this side on shot, you can see how close to the front of the frame member the bolt is:



It could come a little bit forward maybe, but too much and you'll get too close to the edge. It can't go any lower or it will have interference with the center support...

Also the coupler fits better on the frame than it does on the Camplites. There are no washers in between the coupler and the frame, and there is full metal to metal contact between the two. The outer frame members are 2"x6" with the center support at 3", and the center frame member is 4"x6". Then there are big triangular aluminum plates where all three come together.

I think the reason the toyhaulers have the frame so beefed up is because while LivinLite will never come right out and say it, there is no way a half ton truck can pull one of these without a real WD hitch. Mine has over 500 lbs tongue weight when sitting empty (with the propane tanks and battery on the tongue).
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: charliem on February 25, 2016, 10:25:08 AM
[font size="3"]Billmoore,

Interesting pictures. If I understand correctly the center support you refer to is horizontal as shown by my [font color="e63119"]red arrows[/font]. That makes for an interesting extrusion. If so it would prevent the collapse I mentioned. From experience the bending point (pivot point) is at my [font color="e6dd19"]yellow arrow[/font], just ahead of the front vertical bolt. The side bolt should be as far away and forward of that point as possible. I would have tried for somewhere around my [font color="dcd41f"]yellow circle[/font], maybe inside the tube about 1.25" from the front edge and below the center support, but you're there with eyes and hands on and I'm not. [/font][font size="3"]The metal to metal contact is great. [/font][font size="3"]All that said, I think you'll probably be fine. The heavier coupler and side bolts are certainly better than not. The 2x6 frame and 4x6 center tube really point to the intent to haul some serious stuff! Re you last comment, I agree with the need for WDH and, with or without LL's concurrence, it will be used.
 
[attachment id="1214" thumbnail="1"]       [attachment id="1215" thumbnail="1"]

[/font][font size="3"][/font]
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: billmoore on February 25, 2016, 12:45:28 PM
Charlie, yes the red arrows point at the center support. You're right, it is an interesting extrusion, I've never seen tubing like it before.

Where you have the yellow circle would definitely be stronger, but the space is really tight there. It is hard to get a real good look at it right now because the slope where I have the trailer parked puts the tongue too close to the ground to see up in there.

I could angle a camera up in there to get a picture, but I can't get my head under there...  :D  
Title: Newest 2016 21BHS coupler ball size?
Post by: charliem on February 25, 2016, 01:03:33 PM
Quote from: @billmoore" timestamp="1456418728" source="/post/18962/threadCharlie, yes the red arrows point at the center support. You're right, it is an interesting extrusion, I've never seen tubing like it before.

Where you have the yellow circle would definitely be stronger, but the space is really tight there. It is hard to get a real good look at it right now because the slope where I have the trailer parked puts the tongue too close to the ground to see up in there.

I could angle a camera up in there to get a picture, but I can't get my head under there...  :D    
[font size="3"]Bill,  Thanks for your efforts. They really improve my understanding of what LL Thor is up to. To be clear, I'm not suggesting you start drilling unless you just have some spare time. You'll be fine as you are. My point is, given a closer look by LL's engineers, there might be a better placement of the side bolts. I'm also suggesting a placement for Camplite [/font][font size="3"]dealers and [/font][font size="3"]owners who do it themselves. [/font]