I got a chance to look at a couple of truck campers this last week and one was the new 2016 models with several others from years past (2013-2015) On the older models the bottom slide area was covered with a sheet of aluminum while the 2016 model which had the new Extended Seasons package (heated tanks, etc) had an open bottom with just a piece of corrugated plastic covering the bottom. Additionally, it was just laid in there, not attached in any way. Reading the announcement of the 2016 models Ryan Spencer stated about the 2016's "Ryan: There are a few more changes. The ceiling board is now a different color of Azdel. There's also an extra layer of Azdel in the walls, as standard, for improved insulation. Another standard is the fully-enclosed, insulated, and heated underbelly.
On previous CampLite units, the bottom was often open with exposed holding tanks. Now there's a covering across the bottom with insulation. We also added a heat duct that runs from the furnace into the basement. All units with tanks will now have heated basements." Full interview here - http://www.truckcampermagazine.com/news/tcm-exclusive-2016-camplite-announcements
So I am a bit confused. This was definitely not what I would call "fully enclosed." While it would make it easy to work on anything under the belly, it also exposes it to all the elements and I don't care what kind of heat you got pumping to the basement if 11x4 square is exposed to the elements it is not going to stay warm. Also there was no insulation below the tanks. I actually got under the belly and was able to push the plastic aside and look at the tanks and piping. While most of the floor area would be in the camper most of the time, the back overhand also was covered with this corrugated plastic which is going to be shredded in no time as the wind beats it to death driving down the road, let alone all the cold air that would move into this body just pushing the plastic up while moving.
Clarification and maybe some pictures as to the new standard would be great. Thanks!
probably a cost saving measure (they are getting cheap). all of the mainstream manufactureres (forest river/thor/etc) all use the black plastic for their arctic packages. while it is probably more insulating that aluminum, i bet the primary reason was cost.
just another move away from being the "all aluminum:" campers we have been glad to own. at the rate LL is substituting wood and plastic for what used to be aluminum, pretty soon they will be just another manufacturer building their models just like the other manufacturers.
Meh, plastic is almost as moisture-rot resistant as aluminum, which is the whole point of the LL construction method. Finding plastic in place of aluminum and criticizing their "all aluminum claim" is pretty di...well, it ought not be done by reasonable people.
Now, I don't see any of the enclosure methods being particularly necessary when the camper is on the truck. The underbelly of the camper, sitting in the truck bed, is going to be no better/worse insulated by a layer of aluminum, plastic, or phnordnerodinium foil than anything else. If the camper is off the truck, then again, I don't think the thermal coefficient of an aluminum plate is anything more than laughable, compared to plastic, except it is more durable than plastic sheeting. The big solution there is the forced warm air. Whatever contains it does just that - containment.
slippery slope...first it is wood on the face of the cabinets and plastic under the camper...whats next and how far can it go before they lose the all aluminum claim.
as far as the main point being moisture resistant being the whole point of the ll construction method...wasn't light weight part of that as well? lets say moisture resistance was a "contributing factor"
if using plastic isnt significantly adding to the moisture resistance and it is a boat load cheaper, i am gonna put my $ on cost as the driving factor
It's not that its plastic, it's that the bottom is basically open. The plastic was just sitting on it...gaped in a couple of places. I pushed it aside, looked up into the belly and you can see the aluminum flooring, tanks etc...no insulation btw. And like I pointed out the rear portion that hangs out of the bed has the same thing with the black tank exposed. When the GM comes out and says fully enclosed, I would expect something other than a flimsy, no insulation, piece of plastic as the bottom of the enclosure ... but maybe not. Hopefully the factory reps can shed some light on this.
[quote source="/post/16998/thread" timestamp="1449459358" author="@thudd3r"]slippery slope...first it is wood on the face of the cabinets and plastic under the camper...whats next and how far can it go before they lose the all aluminum claim.
as far as the main point being moisture resistant being the whole point of the ll construction method...wasn't light weight part of that as well? lets say moisture resistance was a "contributing factor"
if using plastic isnt significantly adding to the moisture resistance and it is a boat load cheaper, i am gonna put my $ on cost as the driving factor[/quote]I totally forgot that plastic is way heavier than aluminum. Right.
[quote source="/post/16999/thread" timestamp="1449459768" author="@alpha6"]It's not that its plastic, it's that the bottom is basically open. The plastic was just sitting on it...gaped in a couple of places. I pushed it aside, looked up into the belly and you can see the aluminum flooring, tanks etc...no insulation btw. And like I pointed out the rear portion that hangs out of the bed has the same thing with the black tank exposed. When the GM comes out and says fully enclosed, I would expect something other than a flimsy, no insulation, piece of plastic as the bottom of the enclosure ... but maybe not. Hopefully the factory reps can shed some light on this. [/quote]That's my point. It isn't about insulation. Aluminum is a lousy insulator. Plastic is actually better. And in any case, plastic would be sufficient to contain the insulation, if there were any. But none is needed because you can't insulate it well enough anyway. You CAN pump warm air into a loosely contained space, however, and keep the pipes from freezing. Which is all you need.
So you think that when Ryan says, and I quote, "Another standard is the fully-enclosed, insulated, and heated underbelly. On previous CampLite units, the bottom was often open with exposed holding tanks. Now there's a covering across the bottom with insulation." he was talking about an unsecured, 1/8 in piece of plastic. Totally makes sense.
I wonder if the 2016 camper at the show was a completely finished, ready to sell unit? They may have hauled one in there as a demo that didn't have all the underbelly parts installed (maybe even on purpose so attendees could have a look?).
Quote from: @pinstriper" source="/post/17001/thread" timestamp="1449463187Quote from: @thudd3r" source="/post/16998/thread" timestamp="1449459358slippery slope...first it is wood on the face of the cabinets and plastic under the camper...whats next and how far can it go before they lose the all aluminum claim.
as far as the main point being moisture resistant being the whole point of the ll construction method...wasn't light weight part of that as well? lets say moisture resistance was a "contributing factor"
if using plastic isnt significantly adding to the moisture resistance and it is a boat load cheaper, i am gonna put my $ on cost as the driving factor
I totally forgot that plastic is way heavier than aluminum. Right.
not what i was saying but good attempt at taking it out of context.
i was just pointing out that moisture resistance wasnt the "whole point' as you had stated
in the end it is your $...enjoy your next camper made by tupperware ;)
Don't mind seeing quality corrugated plastics on the underside but fastening must be done well and be supportive. Sounds like the attachment leaves room for improvement.
Sure beats tarred cardboard I've seen on other units.... Definitely have heated underbelly envy. Am considering corrugated plastic on my TT at the moment and will heat the underbelly. There is ~9kbtu extra capacity available in our furnace for such foolishness.
Quote from: @thudd3r" source="/post/17027/thread" timestamp="1449549450Quote from: @pinstriper" source="/post/17001/thread" timestamp="1449463187I totally forgot that plastic is way heavier than aluminum. Right.
not what i was saying but good attempt at taking it out of context.
i was just pointing out that moisture resistance wasnt the "whole point' as you had stated
in the end it is your $...enjoy your next camper made by tupperware ;)
If I did buy a truck camper, I would most likely not be worried about 4 seasons, so moot.
All I was trying to say was "don't get your shorts in a knot about ALL-ALUMINUM", which is what I saw from your slippery slope line. A plastic barrier below to hold warmed air in will be pretty much as effective as a thin sheet of aluminum. I wouldn't expect there to be loads of insulation under there, not enough to make warmed air unnecessary, anyway.
Just so y'all know...I'm doing some research on this one.
One of the Livin Lite guys is also helping me out and we are finding one that is TOTALLY finished so that we can report back soon. :-)
Welp. As soon as I sent that, my trusty source walked in with the answer!
The underbelly is fully-heated AND enclosed with a flexible, corrugated composite material. At the time of the interview, the space was insulated...but that process has changed since the interview. :P
The space is heated and enclosed, but no longer insulated. The material it is enclosed with is/should be screwed in so that it is flush with the underbelly- protecting from road debris and vermin (or exceptionally exploratory Grandkids...)
Hope this is helpful and clears things up!
C
C:
Curious. Why does LL now build the truck campers with a bottom enclosure and heated basement and not other CL trailers? I realize that most of us don't care, but some on this forum do camp in freezing conditions, so it would appeal to those if it were at least available as an option.
David
By definition a truck camper has nothing hanging below the sidewalls, so its pretty easy. Our trailers have stuff that hangs low and isnt a problem as long as it has road clearance.
If I'm not mistaken, the 5'ers do have the enclosed plumbing and tanks...or basement.